IRS Offers in Compromise, IRS Payment Plans, IRS Non-Collectible Status, and the IRS’ 10-year statute on collections are all useful tools. But… there are situations where these tools won’t solve the entire problem.
Most people would be surprised to learn that bankruptcy often makes sense as a solution where tax debt exists.
A properly planned case can wipe away the tax debt obligation on many types of tax liabilities and it can solve a host of other problems at the same time, including providing the ability to challenge the validity or the amount of a tax debt when there isn’t another forum available.
But… there are situations where these tools won’t solve the entire problem. Most would be surprised to learn that bankruptcy often makes sense as a solution where tax debt exists. A properly planned case can wipe away the tax debt obligation on many types of tax liabilities and it can solve a host of other problems at the same time, including providing the ability to challenge the validity or the amount of a tax debt when there isn’t another forum available.
Types of Bankruptcy
Two forms of bankruptcy are most often used by individuals and the self-employed: Chapter 7 and Chapter 13. (Chapter 11 is available for individuals as well as companies, but is rarely used)
Chapter 7 is the most common type filed. It is often called a “liquidation” case. A trustee is appointed to protect the interests of unsecured creditors. The secured creditors are protected as they have secured their debt with the property. In theory, this trustee gathers assets that aren’t protected by certain statutory exemptions and sells them. For most people, the statutory exemptions are large enough to protect most of their assets and as a result, most chapter 7 bankruptcy cases are called “no-asset” cases because nothing is actually taken by the trustee and given to creditors. Assets which are acting as security for loans are usually abandoned back to the debtor and remain subject to those liens.
Chapter 13 is for people with regular income (wage based or self-employment based) who are able to pay a reasonable living expense and afford to pay the remainder toward debt each month. Certain other requirements apply as well. There are debt limits, certain debts like back child support, priority tax debt and auto loans, have to be paid in full during the plan. The remainder payment is sent to the Chapter 13 Trustee each month who distributes the money first to the priority creditors, auto lenders and then to other dischargeable credit card debt or tax debt if there are any funds left for them to share. When the time period for the case is over, between 36 and 60 months after it is filed, any remaining dischargeable debt obligation is wiped away.
Effect of Bankruptcy on the IRS
Filing will stop the IRS in it’s tracks. Bankruptcy law ensures that an “automatic stay” against creditors exists at the moment the case is filed. All enforced collection by the IRS will stop. If the IRS has seized assets before the case is filed, but those assets haven’t been liquidated, the bankruptcy trustee can get them and share their value with other creditors according to their priority. This power is important where the IRS has seized assets that are necessary for the operation of a business. Bankruptcy law will also determine how the IRS debt is treated or in other words whether the debt will be considered a priority debt and have first dibs to assets and survive the bankruptcy process, secured debt, or unsecured non-dischargeable debt, or unsecured dischargeable debt.
Secured vs. Unsecured
In bankruptcy, the IRS is just another creditor. It’s a secured creditor like a car lender if a tax lien has been filed and assets exist. It can be an unsecured creditor if no lien is filed. It can also be both if the lien has been filed but the amount owed to it is higher than the equity in the property.
Priority vs. Non-priority
Taxes (like other debts) are categorized as to “priority”. Priority debt means the debt isn’t dischargeable but also that it is first in line when money is paid by the trustee to creditors. A tax debt is a priority debt if the first or third of the following 3 situations exist at the time of the filing. But if any of the 3 exist, the tax is non-dischargeable as well.
- Taxes are non-dischargeable if the return was due less than three years prior to the filing of the bankruptcy petition including extension dates.
- Taxes are non-dischargeable if assessed less than 240 days prior to the filing of the bankruptcy petition.
- Taxes are non-dischargeable if the return was not filed initially by the debtor, or was filed less than two years prior to the filing of the bankruptcy petition.
Tax debts that are non-dischargeable today may become dischargeable “tomorrow”. We carefully plan bankruptcy cases where tax debt is involved in order to ensure our clients get the most benefit from the filing. Extreme care is necessary when dealing in this area of the law.
What else can bankruptcy do?
The U.S. Bankruptcy Code provides a number of benefits and protections for qualifying debtors. The primary benefit is the fresh start it can provide. Freedom from certain debts while allowing the debtor to keep most basic assets is the primary reason people choose to use bankruptcy as an option. But bankruptcy can provide a number of other benefits that are often overlooked.
It can stop collection activity and even collection activity by the IRS. It can cram down IRS and other certain other liens to their values, stop the growth of interest and penalty, allow for the recovery of certain seized assets, force creditors including the IRS to obey a Federal Judge, and provide a forum to challenge debt amounts where other options to do so have been lost.
Analysis is Key
If you have a serious tax debt and/or other debt problems, it is important that you have an experienced tax and bankruptcy attorney review your income, budget, assets, debts, tax debt history and other items to determine whether a bankruptcy will make sense and when.
Some Actual Results
- Client with more than $500,000 in tax debt discharged in bankruptcy.
- Small business client with more than $100,000 in tax debt facing garnishment and possible loss of business – discharged debt in Bankruptcy, saved business.
- Client with more than $28,000.00 tax debt reduced to $0.00 via bankruptcy.
- Client with more than $128,000.00 tax debt reduced to $0.00 via bankruptcy. Tax lien released.
- Client with more than $26,000 in income tax debt and $40,000 in consumer debt reduced to zero in chapter 7 bankruptcy.
- Client with more than $800,000.00 in tax/business related and consumer debt reduced to zero in chapter 7 bankruptcy.
- Client with more than $28,000.00 in income tax and $75,000 in consumer debt reduced to zero in chapter 7 bankruptcy.
- Client with more than $132,000.00 in tax debt and $70,000.00 in consumer debt reduced to zero in chapter 7 bankruptcy. Lien released.
- Client with more than $165,000.00 in tax and consumer debt reduced to less than $11,000.00 in chapter 13 bankruptcy.
- Client with more than $250,000.00 in tax and consumer debt and failed business debt reduced to less than $20,000 in chapter 13 bankruptcy.
- Client with more than $230,000.00 in consumer and tax debt and $115,000.00 in second and third mortgage debts reduced both to less than $10,000.00 in chapter 13 bankruptcy.
- Client with more than $375,000.00 in income tax debt and inability to file offer in compromise, reduced income tax debt to approximately $50,000.00 in chapter 7 bankruptcy
- Client discharged more than $200,000.00 in tax debt in bankruptcy along with more than $75,000.00 in other debt.
- Client with more than $300,000.00 in tax debt discharged in bankruptcy along with more than $150,000.00 in other debt.
- Client discharged more than $100,000.00 in tax debt in bankruptcy and more than $80,000.00 in other debt.